Which statement about the separation of medical care and security responsibilities is NOT true?

The statement that detainee security will be provided by designated medical personnel is not true because it conflates the roles of medical personnel and security staff. In ethical practice, medical personnel are primarily responsible for administering health care and prioritizing patient well-being, while security personnel are tasked with maintaining safety and order. It's crucial to maintain this separation to ensure that medical treatment is not influenced by security concerns, which could compromise the quality of care and ethical standards.

This separation allows for a clear focus on the medical needs of the detainees without bias from security obligations. Additionally, if medical personnel were to provide security, it could create a conflict of interest, wherein the concern for safety could interfere with patient care, violating ethical standards that require compassion and confidentiality in medical practices.

The other statements reflect accurate aspects of the relationship between medical care and security. Medical and security roles can indeed overlap in certain circumstances, such as during emergency situations where decisions might need to be made quickly. Detainees receiving medical care separate from security helps to create an environment where health professionals can focus on diagnosis and treatment without external pressures. Furthermore, the notion that security personnel can make medical decisions undermines the principle of medical expertise and could lead to inappropriate interventions based on non-medical considerations.